Geico and Progressive are two big names in car insurance. They both offer a lot of coverage choices and good prices. But, picking between them depends on what you need and like as a driver. We’ve looked closely at the main differences to help you choose the best one for you.
Key Takeaways
- Geico and Progressive offer similar coverage options, but differ in terms of pricing, discounts, and additional features.
- Geico has a slight edge in overall cost, with lower average rates for most driver profiles, including good drivers, young drivers, and those with clean records.
- Progressive, on the other hand, provides more coverage add-ons and extras, such as gap insurance and a vanishing deductible program.
- Both insurers have strong customer satisfaction ratings, though Geico scores slightly higher in this area.
- The choice between Geico and Progressive ultimately comes down to your personal priorities and the specific coverage needs of your driving situation.
Geico and Progressive: An Overview
When it comes to auto insurance, Geico and Progressive are two big names in the United States. They have long histories and offer many insurance products. Knowing about these companies can help people make better choices for their insurance.
Geico’s History and Offerings
Geico started in 1936, focusing on federal employees and military personnel. Now, it offers car, home, renters, and small business insurance to everyone. It’s the second-biggest auto insurer in the U.S. and is based in Chevy Chase, Maryland.
Progressive’s History and Offerings
Progressive Insurance was founded in 1937 in Cleveland. It insures cars, other vehicles, and more, including homes, renters, businesses, pets, and dental care. Progressive is known for its digital tools and custom pricing.
Geico and Progressive have made their mark in the insurance world. They offer many options to help people protect their money. As the insurance market changes, these companies stay ahead, giving customers many choices.
Comparing Geico and Progressive: Key Differences
Geico and Progressive are big names in auto insurance. They both offer a lot of coverage options. But, there are some key differences that customers should know about.
Industry analysis shows Geico is ahead of Progressive. It’s better in claims handling, customer loyalty, and for senior drivers. Progressive is lower in some areas, like being the most recommended insurer and serving seniors well.
When it comes to customer service, Geico ranks 4th. Progressive is 8th. This means Geico might give a smoother and better experience to its customers.
| Metric | Geico | Progressive |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Rating | Higher | Lower |
| Claims Handling | Better | Worse |
| Customer Loyalty | Better | Worse |
| Best for Seniors | Yes | No |
| Most Likely to be Recommended | Higher | Lower |
| Customer Service Ratings | 4th Place | 8th Place |
These differences show what each auto insurance company is good at and what they’re not. This helps consumers pick between Geico and Progressive more wisely.
“Geico surpassed Progressive not only in their overall rating of the best car insurance companies, but also in a number of subcategories such as claims handling, customer loyalty, and being the best for seniors.”
Geico vs Progressive: Cost Comparison
Cost is a big deal when it comes to auto insurance. Geico and Progressive are often compared by consumers. Geico usually has lower average annual rates for different types of drivers.
Average Rates by Driver Profile
For example, Geico charges $4,908 a year for 17-year-old female drivers. Progressive charges $8,875. For 25-year-old females, Geico costs $1,921, while Progressive costs $2,273. Even for 60-year-old females, Geico is cheaper at $1,625 compared to Progressive’s $1,480.
For high-risk drivers, like those with a DUI, Geico’s rate is $4,323. Progressive charges $2,296, making Geico much more expensive.
State-by-State Cost Comparison
Geico is cheaper than Progressive in about 82% of the country. The map shows Geico is often the more affordable choice. But, rates can change a lot based on where you live. So, it’s smart to compare quotes from both insurers.
| Metric | Geico | Progressive |
|---|---|---|
| Average Monthly Cost (California) | $66 | $86 |
| Market Share (2021) | 14.4% | 13.8% |
| Customer Satisfaction Rating | 4.4/5 | 4.3/5 |
| NAIC Complaint Index | 1.23 | 1.45 |
Geico seems to have better rates by driver and by state than Progressive. This is true for auto insurance pricing and regional rates.
“Geico offers terrific rates for good drivers and discounts for military personnel and federal government employees, while Progressive is favorable for drivers with a DUI conviction.”
Discounts Offered by Geico and Progressive
Geico and Progressive offer many ways to save on auto insurance. They have discounts for safe driving and bundling policies. These can help you cut your insurance costs.
Geico’s Discount Programs
Geico has lots of discounts for different drivers and behaviors. Here are some of their main discounts:
- Air Bag Discount: Up to 23% savings
- Anti-Lock Brakes Discount: Up to 5% savings
- Anti-Theft System Discount: Up to 23% savings
- Daytime Running Lights Discount: Up to 3% savings
- New Vehicle Discount: Up to 15% savings
- Good Driver Discount (Five Years Accident-Free): Up to 22% savings
- Good Student Discount: Up to 15% savings
- Emergency Deployment Discount: Up to 25% savings
- Federal Employee (Eagle) Discount: Up to 12% savings
- Military Discount: Up to 15% savings
- Multi-Vehicle Discount: Up to 25% savings
Geico’s DriveEasy program can save you up to 25% by tracking your driving.
Progressive’s Discount Programs
Progressive also has many discounts for its customers. Here are some of them:
- Multi-Policy Discount: Up to 5% savings with multiple policies
- Multi-Vehicle Discount: Up to 12% savings for multiple cars
- Good Student Discount: Up to 10% savings for students with good grades
- Snapshot Discount: $94 to $231 less each year for safe driving
- Homeowner Discount: Extra savings for homeowners
- Online Signing Discount: Discounts for signing up online
- Teen Driver Discount: Savings for adding a teen to your policy
Progressive’s Snapshot program uses a mobile app to track your driving. This can save you a lot on insurance.
| Discount | Geico | Progressive |
|---|---|---|
| Air Bag Discount | Up to 23% | – |
| Anti-Lock Brakes Discount | Up to 5% | – |
| Multi-Policy Discount | – | Up to 5% |
| Multi-Vehicle Discount | Up to 25% | Up to 12% |
| Good Student Discount | Up to 15% | Up to 10% |
| Snapshot Discount | Up to 25% | Average $94 to $231 in annual savings |
Geico and Progressive both offer many discounts to help you save on insurance. By using these discounts, you could get big savings with either company.
Coverage Options: Geico vs Progressive
Geico and Progressive both offer the basic auto insurance needed in most states. This includes liability, medical payments, personal injury, collision, comprehensive, and more. They also offer optional coverages like mechanical breakdown insurance.
Standard Coverage Offerings
Geico and Progressive have similar auto insurance options. Drivers can find the following with either company:
- Liability coverage: Covers damages or injuries to others in an accident.
- Medical payments/personal injury protection: Pays for medical costs for you and your passengers, no matter who was at fault.
- Collision coverage: Covers repairs if you hit another car or object.
- Comprehensive coverage: Covers damage from theft, vandalism, or natural disasters.
- Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage: Helps if someone with no insurance hits you.
- Emergency roadside assistance: Offers help like towing, flat tire changes, or jump-starts if your car breaks down.
- Rental car reimbursement: Covers the cost of a rental car if your car is in the shop after an accident.
Additional Coverage Options
Geico and Progressive both offer standard coverages, but they differ in extra options. For instance, Progressive has unique add-ons like:
- Vision insurance
- Home security insurance
- Home warranty insurance
- Workers’ compensation insurance
Geico offers mechanical breakdown insurance, which Progressive does not. Both insurers have similar coverage options, making the choice mainly based on individual needs.
In summary, Geico and Progressive both provide the basic and additional insurance coverages needed. It’s important for consumers to look at the details and prices from each to find the best fit for their insurance needs.
Geico vs Progressive: Bundling Policies
Many people look for ways to save money on auto insurance. Bundling multiple policies with one insurer is a smart strategy. Geico and Progressive both offer discounts for bundling that can save you a lot of money.
Geico is known for its low rates and offers various bundling options. You can bundle your auto policy with homeowners, renters, or motorcycle insurance. This can save you up to 25% on your total premium.
Progressive also encourages bundling your auto policy with other insurance types. Pairing your auto policy with homeowners, condo, or life insurance can save you up to 20%.
Both insurers offer discounts for insuring multiple vehicles under one policy. This is great for families or those with more than one car.
| Discount Type | Geico | Progressive |
|---|---|---|
| Multi-Policy Discount | Up to 25% | Up to 20% |
| Multi-Vehicle Discount | Available | Available |
When looking at Geico and Progressive, consider their bundling discounts. If you can get these discounts, either insurer can help you save a lot of money.
“Bundling policies is a smart way to maximize savings on insurance premiums. Both Geico and Progressive offer competitive discounts that can make a real difference in your monthly costs.”
The choice between Geico and Progressive depends on your insurance needs and the discounts you can get. By looking at your options, you can find the best insurer for you and save money.
Customer Service and Claims Experience
Geico and Progressive are known for their customer service and claims handling. Let’s see how they compare.
Geico’s Customer Ratings
Geico is a top choice for customer service, ranking 4th in the MarketWatch subcategory. 57% of Geico customers love the new-policy process. And 52% find filing claims easy.
Geico also does well in keeping customers happy, tying for 4th in customer loyalty.
Progressive’s Customer Ratings
Progressive also offers good customer service, but falls behind Geico. It ranks 8th in the best car insurers for customer service. 58% of Progressive customers are happy with the new-policy process. And 57% like filing claims.
However, 50% of customers find it hard to contact Progressive’s customer service.
From the data, Geico seems to beat Progressive in customer satisfaction. But Progressive is still a strong choice for drivers. It has a good reputation for service and claims handling.
Collision Repair and Claims Process
Handling auto claims is easy with Geico and Progressive. Customers can pick a repair shop from their list or use one they trust. Either way, the claims process is smooth.
At these shops, the insurer takes care of the claim, including getting a rental car if needed. But, if you choose a different shop, you’ll handle the claim yourself.
Choosing the right parts for repairs is important. Progressive’s data shows most parts are new or certified. Only a few are recycled or remanufactured.
The Gross total is the total repair cost, including what you and the insurer will pay. The Total Customer Responsibility shows what you might owe. The Net Estimate Total is the final insurer payment after all adjustments.
Geico tries to get back your deductible and what they paid from the at-fault party. But, they might not always succeed. This could be due to the other party denying fault or not having insurance.
| Repair Part Type | Percentage of Total |
|---|---|
| New OEM or OEM Surplus | 67% |
| A/M Certified or A/M Replacement | 22% |
| Recycled | 5% |
| Remanufactured, Reconditioned, or Recovered | 3% |
“The payment recovery process after a vehicle damage incident usually takes approximately six months, but the duration may vary depending on the circumstances.”
Choosing the right auto insurance provider is important for a smooth claims process. Geico and Progressive both aim to make things easy for their customers.
Conclusion
Choosing an auto insurance provider is a big decision. Geico and Progressive are both top choices in the industry. They offer different benefits that suit various drivers’ needs.
Geico is known for its lower rates, especially for drivers with good credit or clean records. It also has many discounts, making it a great choice for those watching their budget. Progressive, on the other hand, offers more coverage options like gap insurance and coverage for custom parts and equipment. This makes it a good fit for drivers with specific needs.
Choosing between Geico and Progressive depends on your insurance needs, driving history, and what you prefer. It’s smart to get quotes from both companies and a few others. This way, you can pick the best and most affordable policy for you. By comparing carefully, you can make a choice that fits your geico vs progressive needs and choosing auto insurance provider preferences.
2 Comments
Pingback: Progressive vs Geico: Compare Car Insurance Options
Pingback: Geico vs Progressive: Compare Auto Insurance Options